Food Arts Cafe: A Culinary Gem on Fishers Island

Top categories (Breakfast / Beverages / Others)

Welcome to Food Arts Cafe, a charming haven nestled within the pristine landscapes of Fishers Island, NY. Located at 810 Equestrian Ave, this artisanal cafe boasts a delightful array of breakfast and lunch options that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. With a commitment to quality and a warm, inviting atmosphere, Food Arts Cafe is the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy expertly crafted dishes.

Start your day off right with their breakfast offerings, featuring unique selections like the Meat Me At The Cafe and the invigorating Mean Green plate. For something heartier, don’t miss the Southwest Crunch Wrap, Baby or the classic Hashbrown With Any Sandwich, which pairs perfectly with a refreshing Fresh-Squeezed Organic Orange Juice.

For lunch, dive into a variety of mouthwatering sandwiches such as The Cuban, The Big Club, and the delightful Hay Harbor Caprese. Each sandwich is accompanied by a little cup of tomato soup, a thoughtful touch that adds warmth to your meal. The homemade ricotta cookie has garnered rave reviews, a must-try that you won’t want to pass up!

Beyond their diverse menu, the cafe shines in its beverage selection, offering everything from ColdBrewed Coffee to artisanal teas from Harney & Sons. Whether you're sipping on an Iced Chai or enjoying a chilled Lemonade, every drink is crafted to perfection.

Customer experiences echo the quality and care that Food Arts Cafe cultivates. Diners have shared their delight in the friendly staff and cozy environment, with many highlighting the personal touch that Robin, the chef, brings—baking fresh cookies and muffins daily. One customer fondly remarked on the engaging atmosphere fostered by the family-run nature of the business, making each visit feel special.

While some have noted that the prices can be on the higher side, particularly due to the cafe’s remote location, the quality of food and service received makes it a worthy indulgence. The sentiment is clear: the exceptional taste and friendly service make Food Arts Cafe a delightful culinary experience worth savoring.

In conclusion, whether you’re a local or just visiting, be sure to stop by Food Arts Cafe for a delicious meal that celebrates food artistry and community spirit. Your taste buds will thank you!

Takeaway
Dine-in

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Leo Chomen

17/10/2025

The food was extremely good. The only reason it didn’t get a five is the fact that it’s pretty darn expensive. It was lunch and it was two sandwiches and we had two drinks being a soda and lemonade and it was about $52. I know it’s expensive getting food out to Fishers Island so I really don’t know their overhead, though I know I couldn’t eat there every day! Our sandwiches were rather awesome and came with a little cup of tomato soup. I would go there again if my wife upped my allowance.

Jackson Eastman

16/10/2025

Its a pretty good place to go and get a bite to eat.

Will Stadler

26/09/2025

Excellent variety of breakfast and lunch sandwiches, as well as fresh salads dinners and lots of ice cold beverages! Don’t forget a ricotta cookie. (Their specialty)

Ethan Mayers

14/09/2025

We enjoyed our food very much. Got the turkey club and the Jamie (roast beef). Came with a little cup of soup and it's great. Family run business and everyone is so nice. Even bought coffee beans which the owner selected the blend to take home.

Wildblue

07/07/2025

This little cafe packs a big punch! The food is consistently delicious, the staff are very friendly, and the take home food is great. Robin, the chef goes in every morning to bake fresh cookies, and muffins! Need catering? They can handle that as well. Enjoy!

Sam B

02/07/2025

They have a bakery and sandwich shop. It is good but overpriced.

Andrew Godfrey

25/06/2025

We caught it on the last day it was open so you have to wait for next year. The food was delicious in a nice little family run place. Sit and watch the world go by.

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *